The Politics of Managed Care Plans ON THE “EFFICIENCY” OF MANAGED CARE PLANS
نویسنده
چکیده
The claim that managed care plans are more efficient than fee-for-service plans has been made so often that it has reached the status of folklore, but the evidence is inconclusive. The claim is usually based on one or both of the following errors: (1) lower medical care costs mean lower total costs (medical plus administrative costs) and (2) lower HMO premiums mean HMOs are more efficient than fee-for-service plans. The first assertion ignores evidence indicating that managed care has driven up administrative costs for both insurers and providers. The second ignores evidence that managed care plans have numerous methods of shifting costs that are unavailable or less available to fee-for-service plans. The lull in health care inflation during the mid-1990s is often cited as evidence that managed care is efficient. But the lull may have been caused not by the spread of managed care but by the near-simultaneous occurrence of four events: a downturn in the insurance underwriting cycle, the 1990–1991 recession, endorsement of managed competition by numerous politicians, and the merger fever triggered by those endorsements.
منابع مشابه
Physicians' perceptions of commercial and Medicaid managed care plans: a comparison.
Physician participation in fee-for-service Medicaid programs has been declining nationally since the mid-1970s. Numerous studies have documented the reasons for this decline, including poor reimbursement, payment delays, and administrative burdens. Most are now incorporating managed care into their Medicaid programs as an approach to reduce costs. Arizona has the only statewide, mandatory manag...
متن کاملOn the 'efficiency' of managed care plans.
The claim that managed care plans are more efficient than fee-for-service plans has been made so often that it has reached the status of folklore, but the evidence is inconclusive. The claim is usually based on one or both of the following errors: (1) lower medical care costs mean lower total costs (medical plus administrative costs) and (2) lower HMO premiums mean HMOs are more efficient than ...
متن کاملState Medicaid managed care enrollment: understanding the political calculus that drives Medicaid managed care reforms.
The objective of this article is to understand the political motivations underlying Medicaid managed care reforms by examining the determinants of enrollment of beneficiaries in managed care plans in the fifty states. To highlight the role of the model variables, including measures of the political environment, public interest, and special interests, a distinction is made between capitated and ...
متن کاملManaged care's fifteen minutes of fame.
In a world of sound bites and photo ops where everyone has fifteen minutes of fame, it should not be surprising that infatuation with managed care on the part of politicians, the media, and other hucksters has turned to disillusionment and assault. Overreaction to the shortcomings of real managed care plans is an almost inevitable result of the overselling of previous years. He who prospers as ...
متن کاملManaged competition in health care and the unfinished agenda
A market made up of health care financing and delivery plans and individual consumers, without a carefully drawn set of rules to mitigate market failures, and without mediation by collective action on the demand side, cannot produce efficiency and equity. The concept of competition that can achieve these goals, at least to a satisfactory approximation, is managed competition, with intelligent a...
متن کامل